Polk Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Polk bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Fort Polk courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Carseats for Toddlers

who's talking here?

Joycelyn 2
Diana 1
ArmyWife 2
Yuralria 2
Jenn ♥ 3
Sindera 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Joycelyn --- 16 years ago -

My son is 18 months old and is in a convertible carseat but it is reaching its 5 year mark (I used it for my daughter before him) and I have to retire it to get a new one. I was just wondering what kind you guys have used and what you thought the pros/cons were. Right now I'm looking at the Graco ComfortSport Convertible Carseat for $79.87-99.96. My friend suggested the Graco Nautilaus ($135.98). Difference is the first is for up to 40 lbs and the Nautilaus can hold up to 65 lbs on the harness. Is it really worth paying that much more to not have to buy another carseat later down the road??? Much thanks to any of your input.  

Sindera --- 16 years ago -

After working in a Babies R Us, I learned way too much about car seats. Britax is by far the best car seat you can buy, but it comes with a nice price tag with it. Any European brand car seat is tested safe for crashing at speeds of 75 MPH, where American brands need only go up to 45 MPH. However, if I wasn't rich, I'd be very comfortable with a Graco. They use top grade materials and even though they only have to test to 45, they always test higher. I would never buy anything that says Eddie Bauer on it. It's the same as a cosco (which aren't impressive really), but you pay more for the name. Evenflo's are nice, but most people find Graco to be easier to use. Some evenflo's have weird straps that make it difficult for you to get a child in and out quickly. I personally would never buy (or recommend) anything outside of those three brands unless it was a by Baby Trend, but there aren't many Baby Trend convertible carseats. They mostly make infant carriers to go with their strollers. 

Jenn ♥ --- 16 years ago -

I have an Eddie Bauer, and it's nice. It can be buckled in to seatbelt, or use the latch system. Has an adjustable head rest, and the bottom can be removed later to be a big kid booster. Also has 2 cup holders. The other one is one of the $30 ones from walmart, and it has little cushioning to it. 

Sindera --- 16 years ago -

All Car Seats manufactured in the last 3-4 years should have the latch system. I know for sure that both Graco and Britex starting making them mandatory 5 years ago, and all other manufactures were to follow suit by safety regulations. I don't remember what manufacturing year vehicles mandatory starting having the latch system. (Latch system has been proven to be a much safer install than normal, but not by much). The only problem with an Eddie Bauer like that, would be that it's designed more for the kid booster seat. It's not "as" safe for younger toddlers. The adjustable head rest doesn't offer younger toddlers the support they need in a serious collision, and because of it's moving part, I know 3 years ago in testing it had a 10% chance of breaking in a collision at high speeds. They do have the best cup holders though. If you actually read the manual for those models of car seats though, they are actually recommended for not just a weight, but an age of 2 1/2 years and up. Also, they are made by Cosco, so you can cut 30-50 dollars off the cost by just buying the Cosco instead of the Eddie Bauer (they are EXACTLY the same, Eddie Bauer just approves the fabric print and stamps the name on). Sorry, I ramble a lot when I talk baby stuff. I hope I'm not offensive with it. I was just really really well trained. You wouldn't believe the kinds of classes they have for their employees! 

ArmyWife --- 16 years ago -

I have a britax marathon for my daughter and thats what we are getting the baby to be.. It was steep at $250 But can you put a price on safty? 

Jenn ♥ --- 16 years ago -

(Latch system has been proven to be a much safer install than normal, but not by much). Seems a little contradictory to me. How can something be "much safer", but not by much? If you actually read the manual for those models of car seats though, they are actually recommended for not just a weight, but an age of 2 I did read the manual. It has a recommended height of 30 inches and up. My daughter was too short for it when we first got it. Even if its made by cosco, they look different to me, and not just the fabric. 

Yuralria --- 16 years ago -

But can you put a price on safty? but is there a differentce, really in car seats... im not a parent and i have never really looked at them. i just assume thay are mostly the same? 

Jenn ♥ --- 16 years ago -

There are alot of differences. Some are built different. Some have cup holders, thicker cushioning, armrests, no armrests, different features, etc 

Yuralria --- 16 years ago -

ahh, i see. haha , lots to learn 

Diana --- 16 years ago -

My son will be 14 months this month and he has the Evenflo Symphony All-in-One Carseat. I LOVE IT. It has the LATCH System which makes it SUPER easy to get in the Car if your Vehicle supports it. We bought it at BabiesRus on sale, it was the Sophia-Ann Model and this particular design is being discontinued. The padding has pink dots on the flowers but it can not really be seen when he sits in it. They still have it in some stores and i seen it a few weeks ago for under $100. Since your Baby is already 18 months you may not need the rear facing part but you can use it from Newborn until he/she no longer requires a Carseat at all as it converts into a Booster Seat later on (up to 100lb). Also, most Carseats expire after 5-6 years but this one is good for 8 years. http://www.evenflo.com/product.aspx?id=219&pfid=882 

Sindera --- 16 years ago -

(Latch system has been proven to be a much safer install than normal, but not by much). Seems a little contradictory to me. How can something be "much safer", but not by much? Thanks Jenn. The much before safer shouldn't have been there. I blended the two thoughts. Should read "Latch system has been proven to be a safer install than normal, but not by much." I should expound that the extra safety comes from the fact that more people install it correctly with the latch system. If you install it properly the normal way, it's the same. 

Joycelyn --- 16 years ago -

Thanks everyone. It seems that a lot of where I ask, people recommend Britax. So I'm looking into the Britax Marathon. Hopefully when tax season comes around we will get it. :-) 

ArmyWife --- 16 years ago -

I have one if you want to come see one in person, the only bad thing about them is they are big( dont fit in every car rear facing)... But to me thats also a good thing being large and comfy... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
help
recommendations

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Polk Underground